Prompted by the changes, Dietz said last week that he will reopen the case.
While calling it a "significant" step in the right direction, those pushing for reform argue that it's not enough, because it doesn't fully restore funding or address the weights.
Some urban districts, such as Austin, Dallas and Houston, will benefit little from the new funds, as they're classified as property wealthy despite having high concentrations of low-income students. Austin, where 64 percent of the student body come from low-income families, will see an increase of only about $11 million a year over the next two years -- just 23 percent of what was cut in 2011 -- and will continue to face an annual funding gap of $30 million. Elsewhere, in property-poor urban districts -- like San Antonio, which will see its funding restored and then some -- the weights assigned to their high concentration of low-income students aren't enough to get them ahead, some argue.
"You get what you pay for, you definitely don't get what you don't pay for," University of Texas education professor Julian Heilig Vasquez said. "The teacher labor market is like any other market -- the districts that pay more ... get the best teachers. They have rookie teachers, uncertified teachers, in low-performing schools."
Others, however, argue that additional funding won't fix the problem. Providing more options for parents to boost competition in the school system is a better way to address failures in the system, said James Golsan, an education policy analyst at the conservative Texas Public Policy Foundation.
Golsan argued that the state regularly increased the number of raw dollars spent on education leading up to the 2011 cuts, but saw little improvement in student performance. Other factors were at play during that time, however, such as enrollment growth and inflation, that dampened the funding boost.
"We need to start looking at something other than money," Golsan said. "One of the best ways that comes to mind is injecting more competition into our public school system."
Golsan said the state needs to explore options such as vouchers to help middle- and lower-income families afford to send their students to private schools, if they want to do so.
Austin outscores bigger cities
Students from low-income families again struggled on this year's round of the STAAR end-of-course exams. And they struggled on the easier parts of the tests, too.
More Texas students passed the end-of-course exam in biology than any other subject, with 88 percent passing. But its passing rate for low-income students was 5 percentage points lower, with 83 percent passing.
Urban school districts, where most of the low-income students are concentrated, saw similarly low results. In the Dallas school district, where 86 percent of the student body comes from low-income families, only 42 percent passed the writing exam.
In the more affluent Frisco school district, north of Dallas, where just 12 percent of students are from low-income families, 85 percent passed.
Students in the Austin school district performed about on par with the state average. But students in the suburban Leander and Round Rock school districts passed many of the end-of-course exams required to graduate high school at a much higher rate.
In Austin, more than 55 percent passed the writing test, while 74 percent of Leander students who took the test passed, and 69 percent of Round Rock students who took the test passed.
The Austin school district outperformed other urban districts, as it usually does, in part because the appeal of living in Austin helps recruit and retain quality teachers, said Ken Zarifis, president of Education Austin, a labor group that represents district employees. But the district can't count on that to last forever, he said.
"Long term, that's not enough," Zarifis said. "As we see people moving to other districts in Central Texas, we're going to have to find a way to attract people. That's going to be a hurdle that will continue to challenge AISD until we can find a way to pay our teachers."
(c)2013 Austin American-Statesman, Texas
Visit Austin American-Statesman, Texas at www.statesman.com
Distributed by MCT Information Services
Most Popular Stories
- Twitter Names Woman to Board
- Obamacare Doing Just Fine, Ky. Governor Says
- Aspen Contracting Adding 300 Jobs
- Rand Paul Signs up for Obamacare
- Hispanic Employment Improves in November
- U.S. Chamber to Run Ads in Idaho, W.Va.
- U.S. Unemployment Rate Dips to 7 Percent
- Consumer Spending Rises, Incomes Fall
- Trapped Florida Whales Head for Deeper Waters
- American Eagle Issues Weak Q4 Outlook