How gas taxes could change
Davis recommends linking, or indexing, state gasoline taxes to the rate of growth in the costs of concrete, steel and other infrastructure components. No state currently does, although Florida's gasoline tax rate is linked to the inflation rate measured by the consumer price index. Thirteen states link their gas tax rate to the price of gasoline, he says.
Among the funding options being debated in at least 13 states:
Other taxes and fees. Higher sales taxes, new taxes on gasoline stations, higher motor vehicle registration fees and more tolls are among the options being considered in Virginia, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts and Michigan.
In Texas, where the 20-cents-a-gallon gas tax hasn't been raised in 21 years, a state House committee reported in December that the state would have no money for new projects at the current funding level. The Legislature is considering a bill that would rededicate all motor vehicle taxes for transportation. Currently, the money also goes to education and other non-infrastructure expendi- tures.
Raising the gasoline tax. Wyoming appears to be the closest to raising the gasoline tax this year. A proposal to boost it for the first time in 14 years -- from 14 cents a gallon to 24 cents -- passed in the House and is being debated in the Senate. Minnesota lawmakers are mulling a new report from Democratic Gov. Mark Dayton's transportation advisory committee, which recommends higher gasoline taxes and vehicle registration fees. Higher taxes at the pump are also being considered in Massachusetts and Missouri.
But debating raising the tax is far more common than actually raising it. Since 2008, only a handful of states -- including Hawaii, Indiana, Minnesota, Oregon, Rhode Island and Vermont -- and the District of Columbia have raised it, Rall says.
Schank and Davis say that raising gas taxes is politically difficult because politicians have done a poor job of explaining to voters the connection between the taxes they pay at the pump and better roads, less congestion and safer rides.
"People don't like the gas tax when they talk about it in isolation, but they really don't like bad roads," Davis says.
Republican lawmakers in Wisconsin already are rejecting an advisory committee's early recommendations to raise the tax and imposing a mileage-based, vehicle-registration fee.
The federal gas tax has not been raised in two decades, but Congress has supplemented declining revenue by borrowing from the general fund for transportation -- an option not available to most states, which have balanced budget requirements.
Tax by miles traveled. Oregon, Washington and Vermont are among states considering replacing or supplementing the gasoline tax with one that taxes vehicles by the miles they travel. Oregon has legislation that would impose such a tax on 2015 or later-model-year cars that get at least 55 miles per gallon. New federal fuel-efficiency standards passed last year require that by 2025, cars average 54.5 miles per gallon, nearly double the current average.
In Washington, where gasoline tax revenue has been projected to drop by more than $5 billion total between 2007 and 2023, a legislative commission wants to study how such a tax would work.
At least 18 states have studied the idea, Rall says. But no state has moved beyond the experimentation phase and passed miles-traveled taxes on all vehicles, she says.
One problem is privacy concerns, because for the tax to work, cars would have to be equipped with GPS tracking devices that tally the miles driven.
Poole, the Libertarian, favors charging motorists for miles driven. "This is a true user fee, like tolls," he says.
He argues that privacy concerns could be eased by converting existing E-Z Pass transponders, currently used in about half the states, to mileage trackers. "That way," he says, "people don't need any Big Brother technology in their cars."
Most Popular Stories
- Aetna Leaving California's Individual Health Insurance Market
- Is Stock Balloon Really a Pinata?
- G8 Calls for Political Solution in Syria
- Putin Denies He Was Isolated at G8 Summit
- Kanye West's 'Yeezus': Angry Self-love
- Jimmy Hoffa Buried Alive, Reputed Underboss Says
- Google Wants to Share PRISM Information
- Katy Perry: Learned About Divorce Via Text Message
- Boeing to Build Stretch-Dreamliners
- Calories Count: Starbucks to Post the Numbers on Menu Boards