Given the program's success in the Passaic region, some argue that
selective buyouts could be an effective tool to make the Jersey Shore more
resilient as well. There is precedent for buyouts at the Shore: After a
nor'easter slammed the coast in 1962, Sea Isle City condemned two blocks'
worth of storm-damaged property and provided lots for their owners on the bay
side of town, said Mark Mauriello, a former commissioner of the DEP.
But he acknowledged buyouts can become a hot-button item. "The debate
gets polarized" between those who think people should abandon shoreline
property completely and those who want to stand firm and harden the shoreline
everywhere. "There's a middle ground," he said. "Hold the line -- and pull
back in certain spots."
The Passaic River basin has come under seven federal disaster
declarations since 2005. In the past two decades, floods have caused more than
$3.5 billion in losses. Hurricane Irene last year caused the region's worst
flooding in a century, producing enough rainfall to qualify as a 500-year
storm event in the Passaic's upper watershed.
In the early 1990s, the corps proposed a $2.1 billion, 20-mile tunnel and
levee system to divert runoff after heavy storms from the Passaic watershed
out to Newark Bay. The idea stalled over concerns about costs and the scale of
the project. Today, a tunnel diversion project would cost an estimated $2.7
billion, according to the corps.
A system of levees and floodwalls along with dam and bridge modifications
could achieve much of the same protection from significant storms for less
than $1 billion, the corps has estimated.
But levees and can also fail -- as happened with the storm surge swept up
the Hackensack, overwhelming Meadowlands levees and swamping Little Ferry and
Moonachie the night Sandy hit.
"We're going to have flooding," said Miller, the water resource engineer
on the Passaic River Basin Flood Advisory Commission. "There's no single
answer."
The devastating storms that have struck New Jersey also have local and
state officials talking about building infrastructure that will be able to
withstand what some are calling weather's "new normal."
James Weinstein, NJ Transit's executive director, said more than $800
million is needed to make the system more resilient to storms. More than 300
railcars and locomotives -- a quarter of the state's rolling commuter stock --
were damaged by Sandy.
The massive power outages caused by both Irene and Sandy -- about 80
percent of the state's population lost power after Sandy alone -- also renewed
talk of burying electrical lines to make storm-caused blackouts a thing of the
past. But that could cost an average of $724,000 per mile, according to the
Edison Electric Institute, a power industry group. Experts say the expense and
work required for such a major construction project make the endeavor highly
unlikely, especially in such densely populated areas as North Jersey. And
buried lines are susceptible to corrosion by saltwater intrusion in shore
areas, some experts say. Among those against the idea are the power companies,
as well as Christie.
"A million dollars a mile, in this state?" he said after Sandy, citing
the higher end of industry cost projections. "I think the cost-benefit
analysis there is pretty obvious."
But other projects could cost far less. For example, backup generators in
hospitals and other essential buildings need to be brought out of flood-prone
basements.
When a 5-foot wave of Newark Bay water crashed across the facilities at
the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commission's huge plant in Newark during
superstorm Sandy, much of the equipment, located in tunnels below ground, was
ruined. The backup generators were knocked out. As a result, millions of
gallons of untreated sewage poured into the Passaic River.
Michael DeFrancisci, the commission's executive director, said later that
the doors to the facility's tunnels were not watertight -- and that a top
priority will be to install watertight doors.
Tim Crowley, FEMA's regional director for mitigation, said that as it
recovers from Sandy, New Jersey can use the opportunity to do more than
rebuild what was damaged or destroyed. "It's a chance to seize the day to
build more disaster-resilient communities," he said.
Mauriello, the former DEP commissioner, said that while Sandy was a
"scary wake-up call," New Jersey doesn't need to look far for some of the best
ways to make the state more resilient to future storms. "We don't have to
wonder where it's been done -- it's already been done right here. We have
successes," he said, citing the beach replenishment program as an example.
"Right now we have a brief window to push things forward," he said.
"Because down the road, as we get a few months past the storm, the energy
fades."
Most Popular Stories
- Entrepreneurs Chase Social Media
- European Car Sales up First Time in 20 Months
- Schedule packed with talent at the Fox
- Manila's Hollywood Week
- I never set out to be a role model but it's great to be one ; IN THE HOTSEATBetter known by his stage name Wretch 32, Jermaine Sinclair is a 28-year-old rapper from London. In 2011 his debut album Black and White sold over a million copies and scored three top five singles. His latest single Blackout was released this week
- Austin musicians point to a variety of reasons to appreciate McCartney
- Financial Times Twitter, Email Hacked
- Apple's iPhones, iPads Approved for Military Use, Sir Yes Sir!
- SINCE YOU ASKED [Pittsburgh Tribune-Review (PA)]
- Promoter McLean 'provided more musical joy than Dylan and Prince combined'
News-To-Go
Advertisement
Advertisement
News Column
Protecting North Jersey From Future Storms Could Cost Billions
Page 4 of 4
Source: (c)2012 The Record (Hackensack, N.J.) Distributed by MCT Information Services
Story Tools



