The stock prices of companies that use the same lead underwriter during their equity offerings tend to move together, according to a new study by financial economics experts at
"We tested the hypothesis that investment banking networks affect stock prices and trading behavior," said
An equity offering is an invitation by an underwriter to the general public or a select group of investors to buy a new issue of a company's common stock.
Weston said the magnitude of the effect is similar to the "co-movement" that research has linked to share price, stock index inclusion, specific industry or geography. He co-authored the paper with
The authors provided an example to illustrate their findings: "
The authors also found that when firms switch underwriters between their initial public offering (IPO) and a seasoned equity offering (SEO), they co-move less with the stocks associated with the old bank and more with the stocks associated with the new bank. "This change in co-movement is greater for stocks completing their first SEO and for those experiencing large changes in institutional ownership," Weston said.
The authors illustrated this phenomenon using their initial example. "Now suppose an exogenous force causes firm F to switch underwriters for its next security offering, and it moves from JPMorgan to Goldman," they wrote. "Now, IGoldman obtains better information about firm F than IMorgan, which causes the stock returns of firm F to move less with D and E (its old network) and more with A, B and C (its new network)."
The authors said their results are likely driven by the existence of distinct clienteles or networks of segmented investors created by privileged information flow between the investment bank and investors. "While it has long been noted that investment banking relations can create such information channels, we present new evidence that this has an effect on asset prices and trading behavior through co-movement," they said. In other words, companies are not just hiring an investment bank; they are hiring for future performance.
"In general, the results in this paper highlight the importance of investor networks on asset prices, and they underscore the effect of networks on the institutional investors' demand for stocks," the authors wrote.
To arrive at their findings, the authors created two samples of all equity offerings between 1980 and 2008 from the Securities Data Corporation Platinum database. The first sample consisted of 2,540 IPOs in which a firm uses a single lead underwriter. The second sample contained 2,869 SEOs in which a single underwriter leads both the SEO and the previous equity offering. Among the sample of SEOs, 1,511 used the same bank from the previous offering and 1,358 switched investment banks.
For a copy of the study, "Co-movement and Investment Banking Networks," e-mail firstname.lastname@example.org.
TNS 18DejucosGrace-140808-30FurigayJane-4823283 30FurigayJane
Most Popular Stories
- Rackspace Ends Talks About Possible Acquisition
- Mercedes Rolls Out S550 Plug-in Hybrid
- Plus-Size iPhones Live Up to The Hype
- FedEx Adding 50,000 Holiday Jobs
- Missouri GM Plant Adding 750 jobs
- Cool Features on Today's New iOS 8
- Toxic Algae Threatens Florida Fishing, Tourism
- Family Dollar Spurning Bid From Dollar General
- Kohl's Hiring 67,000 for the Holidays
- Poverty Rate Drops for First Time Since 2006