WHAT remains of the Bank of
The value of guidance from a central bank should be to provide a consistent and reliable indication of how it is thinking about its decisions and the future course of interest rates. That should help the public and businesses plan for the future. Instead, we have had shifting goalposts, and rather confused messages about future policy. The first version of forward guidance - launched around this time last year - appeared to provide clarity. There were two main messages. A rise in interest rates would not be considered until unemployment had fallen below 7 per cent. And that was not expected to happen until 2016 or later. So the general impression was very clear - relax and enjoy a long period of low interest rates.
According to this first version of forward guidance, such progress should have led to a vigorous debate on interest rate policy among members of the MPC.
But that has not happened. All members of the Committee continue to vote to keep the Bank rate at 0.5 per cent - the level set in
This was a much more vague policy, which emphasised the need to look at the margin of spare capacity in the economy more broadly, and to take account of "economic developments" in setting interest rate policy. The centrepiece of this second version was that interest rate rises would be gradual and limited - the official Bank rate was not expected to return to its level before the crisis.
This is the official guidance from the MPC which is still in place. But with yesterday's Inflation Report and press conference, we appear to have moved to a version three. Unemployment is falling sharply, and economic growth is picking up. According to the Bank, growth will be over 3 per cent this year and next - double the average rate so far since the financial crisis. A whole host of other indicators - retail sales, car registrations, house prices, housing market transactions - point to an improving economy.
In forward guidance version three, there are two new key indicators. First of all, wage growth - which is very subdued, according to official figures. Second, interest rates may not rise because of adverse developments in the global economy. "Even if spare capacity was eliminated at a stroke, the level of the Bank rate may not rise materially above its current level because of global economic headwinds",
Very subdued wage growth is a puzzle in the
Last August, when forward guidance was first launched, the Bank's Inflation Report featured 26 references to the word "guidance". It was the same in
The concept of forward guidance has not delivered. It seems to have been used to support the view that interest rates will not rise, rather than preparing the public and business for inevitable hikes. Let's hope the MPC can adapt its policy and make it more credible. But it has not had a good start.
Most Popular Stories
- Study: Recessions Can Postpone Motherhood Forever
- Tim Cook Has Proved That Apple is His Baby
- Hispanic Entrepreneurs Short-changed in Texas
- China Approves iPhone 6 After Security Assurances
- U.S. Home Prices Rose at Slowest Pace in 20 Months
- Meet the YouTube Tech Review Sensation
- Who Is Daniel Ivascyn?
- PBS Series Examines America's Demographic Shift
- Hispanics Carry Big Clout: Census
- Netflix Eyes Hollywood With Feature Film