In my last column, I explored some of the political history of statist economic policies toward foreign investors in the mining sector, a conversation which has been prompted by the recent calls for more government "action" on the
KCM is currently majority owned by
When a peculiar activist group known as "Foil Vedanta" began attacking the company late last year, in
Resource Nationalism Under the PF
Now, since the fall of 2011 when the
One of the first negative moves made by the PF financial team was a 100% increase in royalty tax, doubling it from 3% to 6%, making
The PF appear to be walking head first into the same situation created by Mwanawasa's haphazard mismanagement when
Perhaps the mood of the new party was best expressed by the Finance Minister
What a disappointing statement emanating from a minister. In all fairness, if someone comes across fraudulent activities, the right thing to do is prosecute, otherwise keep quiet. It is uncouth to accuse someone solely on the basis of superstitions rather than evidence. Simply, it is not the modern way of resolving economic problems.
Activists Add Fuel to the Fire
The arrival of the report by the Foil Vedanta group in
I personally read the 35-page report and concluded that it was nothing but a sensational report that had little or no facts. Most notably, the report relied on hearsay from all sorts of people and presented the rumours as the gospel truth. No surprise when Kaunda was quoted in the same report accusing the Zambian mines of "gushing out profits."
With regard to the video, I'm of the opinion that if the video were a true account, then it could only have been made as a ruse to goad us into taking an irresponsible action. Nationalisation, expropriation. It was gratifying for once to see the government take a sensible position when they refused to give into calls from the street to nationalise. It is also important to note whilst other parties and interested groups played populist, because they leap upon any opportunity to attack the PF, the
What was also amazing was the opinion of a professor at a business school in the Copperbelt on the subject of nationalisation. The professor was in support of nationalisation, but at the same time cautioned us to be aware of the international community. From what parallel universe such a skewed perspective is possible from an educated man, I cannot imagine.
Expectations have been pretty low for this government, and they've displayed statist tendencies in the past with the re-nationalisation of Zamtel, the stripping of railroad licenses, and the gradual takeover of more parastatal companies. But on KCM, so far, the PF have been relatively pro-investor rights.
The Way Forward
The fact that nationalisation would be disastrous and the fact that our populist politics are often more driven by emotion than evidence does not mean that everything is OK with mining in
But we must not worship false idols. Most people believe the income derived from mining activities will to a large extent act as a panacea to most of our problems in our country. This is a terrible misconception.
We simply do not understand the role that mining plays in our economy. Contrary to most beliefs the mining sector only forms 13% of our gross national product - we are an agricultural nation when it comes to jobs and self-sufficiency. But the mining sector provides 80% of our foreign exchange through mineral exports. The mines also accounted 82% of our foreign direct investment received in our country.
As such, the mining sector is the proverbial 'goose that lays the golden egg,' but it looks like we want to kill the goose by implementing short-sighted government actions as aforementioned in this article. Actions that have contributed to the drying up of foreign direct investment by mines and slowed mine output in our country. In the case of KCM, production has actually fallen in 2014 resulting in a loss of
The major player in our economy is Agriculture. Agriculture related activities occupy 60% of our GNP (economy) and most of our people derive their income from it. The other 30% is in service industries and construction/manufacturing. Let us therefore focus and direct our energies in resolving problems in the big areas of our economy i.e. Agriculture and energy
The way forward is for the government to immediately reverse all the unstable fiscal policies from the time of Mwanawasa's rule and up to date. Promote cordial relationship with the business community now. And we should also abide to growth oriented market principles which most successful countries have adopted. The government should also remove the structural imbalances in agriculture and energy by letting market forces take a commanding role.
To do otherwise and not correct policy mistakes is to succumb to "poetic justice" as prophesised in the remarks made by the former MMD Minister Katele Kalumba on welcoming the PF in office in 2011. Katele said: "President Sata has come into office to finish the work that President Kaunda left."
That, indeed, would be very bad for all Zambians.
Most Popular Stories
- Criminal Investigation Opened Into James Foley's Death
- Koch Brothers Took Genes, Money in Different Directions
- Rocket Explodes During U.S. Test Flight
- Short-Term Loans Comes at a Heavy Price
- Is Diversity in the Eye of the Beholder?
- Apple Stock Bounces Back Big Time
- 'Mythbusters' Build Team Gets the Boot
- Jennifer Lopez Would Marry Again
- Florida Judge Rules in Favor of GOP Voter Map
- Investors Betting on ECB Stimulus Measures