More than 600,000 undergraduates attend four-year "college dropout factories" with six-year graduation rates below 15 percent and "diploma mills" where nearly 3 out of 10 students who leave with debt are unable to repay their student loans, according to a new report released by
The report, Tough Love: Bottom-Line Quality Standards for Colleges, lays out a comprehensive plan for the federal government to leverage existing resources, in the form of student aid and tax benefits, to protect students and taxpayer dollars from going to chronically underperforming schools. The plan also encourages elite colleges to open their gates to many more talented working class and low-income students.
"The federal government writes a
"Students who are receiving federal financial aid to get a college education should, at the very least, be guaranteed that their school meets minimum performance standards. And taxpayers providing generous financial aid and tax benefits to elite institutions, ranging from
At a time when controversy is swirling about the Obama administration's proposal to rate colleges and eventually tie financial aid benefits to those ratings,
Schools would confront consequences if their Pell Grant-eligible, full-time freshman enrollment is less than 17 percent; six-year, full-time freshman graduation rates are under 15 percent; or student loan repayment rates rank in the bottom 5 percent.
Of undergraduates attending schools with low graduation and student loan repayment rates, an estimated 100,000 will default on their federal student loans within three years of exit. For first-time, full-time students attending a "college dropout factory," their chances of leaving school with no degree are nearly six times higher than their chances of graduating. Nearly 1 in 2 won't make it to their sophomore year. And those who drop out after just one year of attendance leave with nearly
Additionally, colleges that operate as "engines of inequality" present serious consequences for highly talented students from working class and low-income families. Students who are shut out from elite colleges and "undermatch" into institutions significantly less rigorous than those for which they are qualified to attend are 15 percentage points less likely to complete a degree.
* Low-access colleges, or "engines of inequality," would have three years to improve, succeeding if the average Pell Grant enrollment rate equals or exceeds 17 percent. If they do not improve in this time frame, they would lose institutional tax and grant benefits, including tax-exempt bonds eligibility and the charitable interest deduction to both the institution and affiliated foundations.
* "College dropout factories" would have four years to improve, succeeding if the average graduation rate equals or exceeds 15 percent. They would receive two additional years for improvement, if they are on track to graduate at least 15 percent of students by the end of six years. If they do not improve, they would lose institutional tax and grant benefits, as well as all eligibility to confer federal student aid, including grant, loan, and tax aid.
* "Diploma mills" would also have time to improve. A specific time frame is to be determined upon availability of student loan repayment data, but it should be at least three years. If these schools fail to improve, they would be subject to the same consequences as "college dropout factories."
"Schools falling beneath the bottom fifth percentile on these measures represent the 'worst of the worst,'" said
Most Popular Stories
- Americans Still Pessimistic Despite Economic Growth
- New Hershey's Logo Revealed
- Obama's Delay on Immigration Creates Uncertainty
- Obama on Labor Day: Don't Take Rights for Granted
- Buyer's Remorse on Common Core for Policymakers?
- Mexico's Pemex Forecasts 6.7% Drop in 2014 Crude Production
- California Passes First US Statewide Bag Ban
- American Airlines Back on Obitz
- Echeveste Steps Down, Perez Steps Up at VPE
- Startups Offer Smartphone Banking Apps