The suit involves one permit in
It happens, for instance, when several siblings jointly inherit land, and some then sell their interest.
In cases where ownership of the surface and the underlying coal have been severed, the federal surface-mining law requires a coal company to get permission to mine the site from all the co-owners, according to the suit.
However, the state has long taken the position that any one of the co-owners can give permission to mine -- even one that owns only a 1 percent interest; the state often issues surface-mining permits with the OK of only a minority of owners, which then gives companies leverage over the other owners, Childers said.
"It's a hammer over their heads," he said Thursday.
State regulators "firmly believe" that the permit at issue in the federal lawsuit was properly and legally issued, said
The case involves a 400-acre hollow in
When Premier Elkhorn applied for a permit to mine on about 180 acres, it listed
Five of the heirs -- who jointly have a 62.5 percent ownership interest -- are challenging the permit at the state level and in the federal lawsuit.
"There's a lot of sentimental value to this holler," said Johnson, 67, who worked as underground miner for 37 years. Johnson lives at the mouth of the hollow, but built a cabin higher up the ridge, near the site of Premier Elkhorn's permit. He said it isn't fair that a minority owner could override the wishes of majority owners.
The lawsuit argues that the state ran afoul of federal law by approving a permit application that did not list the names and addresses of all the owners. As a result, the Johnson heirs did not get a chance to comment on the permit while it was under consideration, the suit said.
The complaint also argues the state erred by approving the application when it did not include written consent from all the landowners.
The lawsuit is not against the state or coal company, but rather against
The lawsuit seeks an order for Premier Elkhorn to stop mining at the site and asks that Jewell be ordered to put a new system in place for issuing surface-mining permits in
(c)2014 the Lexington Herald-Leader (Lexington, Ky.)
Visit the Lexington Herald-Leader (Lexington, Ky.) at www.kentucky.com
Distributed by MCT Information Services