News Column

Quintet performance melts memories of the snow

February 15, 2014

By David Patrick Stearns, The Philadelphia Inquirer

Feb. 15--Storm? What storm?

The Kimmel Center's Perelman Theater was populated as if nothing unusual was happening outside Thursday, and even picked up extra listeners from the canceled Philadelphia Orchestra, whose members took the opportunity to hear the Berlin Philharmonic Wind Quintet.

"You must be brave," said the quintet's hornist Fergus McWilliam to the audience. "But then, we got here, too."

Though a specialized instrumentation with a slim repertoire, the wind quintet's program was anchored with two formidable works that would be known more widely if always heard in the caliber of performance delivered by the Berliners Thursday in a Philadelphia Chamber Music Society concert.

That the lineup didn't include the orchestra's star flutist Emmanuel Pahud was of little consequence. Berlin Philharmonic's distinctively full-bodied sound and overall musical ethics were very much embodied in this quintet, whose members include flutist Michael Hasel, oboist Andreas Wittmann, clarinetist Walter Seyfarth and bassoonist Marion Reinhard. The blend was always airtight, often converging into hybrid timbres that subsumed the individual sounds.

Carl Nielsen's Wind Quintet Op. 43 tapped that quality to extra-worldly ends: This masterwork is truly its own musical world, one that reveals numerous other realms within, all oddly gnarled, the more dense moments suggesting a rain forest in a parallel universe. A performance like this probes parts of the soul you didn't know about.

What it all means feels less out of reach than in Nielsen's later, high-density symphonies, thanks to the Wind Quintet's kinship with the composer's extroverted operas. McWilliam played his final-movement horn solo with highly personal rhetoric suggesting he had applied method acting to his phrase readings.

Kalevi Aho's 2006 Kvintetto, the concert's other major work, suggested that this Finnish composer is incapable of writing anything without an epic quality. With its marginal relationship to tonality, this piece was a lot about dichotomies, with movements divided into contrasting halves and the quintet itself tapped for its potentially contrasting sounds (the oboe brayed abrasively). Most arresting were moments when an individual instrument created a quiet undercurrent using long-held notes behind the other instrument's chatter. Quintet members even took turns playing offstage in the last movement, sounding like a distant choir that kept mutating.

The rest of the concert had Mozart's accomplished but dutiful Fantasie in F Minor K. 608 and Darius Milhaud's charming reconstituted film score La CheminÉe du roi RenÉ that didn't leave the slightest footprint in one's memory.


(c)2014 The Philadelphia Inquirer

Visit The Philadelphia Inquirer at

Distributed by MCT Information Services

For more stories covering arts and entertainment, please see HispanicBusiness' Arts & Entertainment Channel

Source: Philadelphia Inquirer (PA)

Story Tools