News Column

'Monsters University' Review

June 23, 2013
Monsters University, Review

"Monsters University" is funny, and the animation is beautiful.

It is not, however, as unique or as inspired or as charming as the Pixar standard has led us to believe we should expect from its films. The movie is fun but also a bit forgettable.

The price of success comes in being compared to your best work, and Pixar's "Toy Story" movies, "The Incredibles" and "Wall-E" are masterpieces of animated moviemaking.

So many of the company's films have been subversively edgy in their G-rated filmmaking, while retaining a keen ability to touch our hearts. "Monsters, Inc.," the 2001 predecessor to the new film, certainly fell into this category.

That movie scared up laughs while taking us into another world where monsters of all shapes and sizes entered magical doorways into children's bedrooms, becoming the bump in the night and the creature under the bed and ultimately eliciting little ones' screams of terror -- which provided the juice to power the electrical needs back home in the monsters' world.

Now that's inventive. The animators pulled it off in a way that was magical, and the storytellers balanced that conceit against the buddy-comedy teaming of the furry bear-like Sulley (voiced by John Goodman) and one-eyed green imp Mike (with a frenetic Billy Crystal bouncing off Goodman's good humor).

Imagination like that, more than anything, is what's lacking in "Monsters University."

It feels like the people involved decided: Let's show how Sulley and Mike first met in college, and we'll throw in a little bit of "National Lampoon's Animal House" and so much of "Revenge of the Nerds" that the 1984 film's writers should receive a story credit.

The initial scene amuses as we meet a young Mike Wazowski, who's short on friends but long on his desire to become a top scarer at Monsters, Inc. His dream is to one day attend Monsters University, where all the best scarers go to college.

Thus begins a series of frat-party jokes, dorm-room drollery, cafeteria clowning and freshman farces as unscary know-it-all Mike and humongous but lazy and arrogant Sulley butt heads. Their feud intensifies as both are kicked out of the scaring program when their goofing off destroys a souvenir belonging to the dean (Helen Mirren) of the School of Scaring.

Mirren's monstrous Dean Hardscrabble -- a dark red dragon-like monster with millipede legs and red bat wings -- apparently knows how to hold a grudge. The Oscar-winner is left in the thankless role of a half-baked villain type as she watches ousted Mike and Sulley band together with a group of misfit dorm monsters, hoping to win the Scare Games and return to the School of Scaring.

It was called the Greek Games in "Revenge of the Nerds," and this picture follows that script to obvious conclusions.

At least "Monsters University" is frequently funny. It has to be to cover for the lack of cleverness in the story.

Rather than serving up gags that mix in with the story, the movie is an assembly line of sight gags (Sulley sheds, the misfit fraternity surprises with nerd-like skills, Mike kvetches). There is excellent artistry in the visuals, and Goodman and Crystal delight as a big guy-little guy team in the Laurel and Hardy vein.

But "assembly line" is not what anyone wants from Pixar. At least "Monsters University" is a small step up from the sequel "Cars 2," which felt like it was more about the merchandising than the yarn, but should we also expect diminishing returns from "Finding Dory," a 2015 sequel to "Finding Nemo," another beloved Pixar film?

The simple beauty of the animated short film "The Blue Umbrella" (strangers meet cute in a rainstorm) playing before the main attraction had my audience oohing and ahhing at the emotions and the originality of this gorgeous little movie.

I missed experiencing a similar lump in the throat that I thought "Monsters University" would induce and that makes Pixar movies memorable.

Michael Smith 918-581-8479


(c)2013 Tulsa World (Tulsa, Okla.)

Visit Tulsa World (Tulsa, Okla.) at

Distributed by MCT Information Services

Source: Copyright Tulsa World (OK) 2013

Story Tools Facebook Linkedin Twitter RSS Feed Email Alerts & Newsletters