News Column

Jolie Mastectomy Raises Legal Questions

May 17, 2013
Angelina Jolie

The revelation this week by the film star Angelina Jolie of a double mastectomy to help avoid breast cancer had business and legal angles as well.

Myriad Genetics, the Utah company at the center of a legal debate about the acceptability of gene patenting, has a monopoly on the testing Jolie underwent before opting for surgery.

With the news about Jolie breaking Tuesday morning, the company's stock rose to a three-year high of $34.70 during trading on the Nasdaq before closing at $34.10. The trading volume, with 2.6 million shares exchanged, was more than double the three-month daily average of 1.1 million shares.

By Thursday's close, the stock had fallen into $33.13.

Jolie explained her decision in an op-ed piece in the New York Times.

"The cost of testing for BRCA1 and BRCA2, at more than $3,000 in the United States, remains an obstacle for many women," Jolie wrote, referring to the genes. A mutation of the genes can indicate a greater chance of cancer.

Myriad spokesman Ron Rogers said Wednesday that while the company wished Jolie well and was pleased that she encouraged other women with a family history of breast and ovarian cancer to get tested, the company disagreed with her on the cost being an obstacle. Rogers said insurance covers 95 percent of patients with a co-payment of about $100. For those without insurance, the company offers discounts, and provided 5,000 free tests in the past three years. The Affordable Care Act will require insurers to cover such tests.

"Everyone who is at risk should absolutely go get the BRCA test," Julie Kessel, Cigna's senior medical director overseeing the coverage policy unit, was quoted as saying in a story on

Women who could not afford the test in previous years were among the original plaintiffs in a lawsuit that is pending before the U.S. Supreme Court. The basic issue is whether Myriad _ or any company or person _ should be allowed to patent on a human gene. The court heard oral arguments April 15 and is likely to issue a decision before the end of the current term in June.

Myriad's stock price had already risen in the past week, bolstered by its quarterly earnings report. The company is heavily dependent on the revenue from testing for these genes.

"Revenue from the BRACAnalysis test, which represented 74 percent of total revenue in the third quarter, was $115.4 million, a 9 percent increase over the same period of the prior year," Myriad said in a news release that accompanied its report.

Monday's Supreme Court decision on seed patents in favor of Monsanto in Bowman v. Monsanto et al. might have also been a factor. reported that William Blair analyst Amanda Murphy said in an email that she believed the Monsanto decision was a bigger factor in Tuesday's stock movement than Jolie's announcement.

Murphy said the court recognized the investment that companies like Monsanto have to make in research and development, and that issue was also discussed during oral arguments in the Myriad case.


(c)2013 The Philadelphia Inquirer

Visit The Philadelphia Inquirer at

Distributed by MCT Information Services


For more stories covering arts and entertainment, please see HispanicBusiness' Arts & Entertainment Channel

Source: Copyright Philadelphia Inquirer (PA) 2013

Story Tools Facebook Linkedin Twitter RSS Feed Email Alerts & Newsletters