News Column

Sickening Stench Aboard Carnival Triumph

Feb. 13, 2013

Gene Sloan, USA TODAY

The Carnival cruise ship disabled by a fire in the Gulf of Mexico was being towed to Alabama on Tuesday amid reports of miserable conditions for the 4,229 people on board.

Passengers on the 102,000-ton Carnival Triumph who have been able to reach relatives and news outlets have described overflowing toilets and a stench so bad that it was making some passengers sick.

Brian Nutt said his wife, a passenger, told him in a call from the ship: "There's water and feces all over the floor. The whole ship stinks extremely badly."

Nutt said his wife described passengers throwing up from the stench. "You would think Carnival would have something in place to get these people off the ship," he said.

Carnival CEO Gerry Cahill said Tuesday that his company is trying to make the passengers as comfortable as possible while the ship is being towed to Mobile, Ala.

Cahill said the ship has running water and most of its 23 public restrooms and some of the guest cabin bathrooms are working. He said the ship hasn't seen an abnormal number of people reporting to the infirmary as being ill.

"No one here from Carnival is happy about the conditions onboard the ship," Cahill said at a news conference in Miami. "We obviously are very, very sorry about what is taking place."

The National Transportation Safety Board announced Tuesday it has opened an investigation into the cause of the fire. The NTSB said the Bahamas Maritime Agency will lead the investigation because the ship carries a Bahamian flag.

The Carnival Triumph was left dead in the water early Sunday after a fire in an engine room. Although the blaze was contained, Carnival said, it knocked out power that runs air conditioning, elevators and toilets in passenger areas and kitchen equipment to prepare hot meals.

The vessel's freshwater system was knocked down until Monday, Carnival said, when toilets in some areas of the ship were working again. Enough power was restored to allow for some hot food at a buffet.

Still, conditions have remained difficult. Passengers relayed stories of long lines for meals and people sleeping on open decks.

It emerged Tuesday that the ship had been listing about 4.5 degrees on Monday, which Carnival attributed to strong winds. Carnival spokesman Vance Gulliksen said the list diminished to about 2 degrees on Tuesday after tugboats began towing the vessel. The listing poses no safety risk, Carnival said.

The cruise line evaluated options and decided the safest alternative was to tow the ship back to port, Gulliksen said.

Because Carnival ships tend to sail full, there may have been no space to accommodate passengers on other ships, retired cruise line executive Art Sbarsky said.

"Given a choice, I'd rather be on a ship the size of Triumph than bobbing around in a (life boat)," he said.

The Carnival Triumph has been under tow since late Monday, when the first of two tugboats arrived to pull the vessel to Mobile. It's scheduled to arrive Thursday afternoon.

The ship was 150 miles from the coast of Mexico when it lost power, and Carnival initially planned to tow it to the Mexican port of Progreso. But strong currents pushed the ship 90 miles north by the time the tugs arrived, making a tow to Alabama more logical.

None of the 3,143 passengers and 1,086 crew on board the Carnival Triumph was injured during the fire, and only one medical issue has since been reported. On Monday, a passenger in need of dialysis was transferred to the Carnival Legend for transport to Cozumel, Mexico. The Legend also provided meals for passengers on the Triumph -- and a chance for some passengers to communicate with home.

With much of the power on the Carnival Triumph down, passengers with cellphones have been able to call and text only during brief periods when another Carnival ship with connectivity pulls alongside -- a fact that has left some family members back at home frustrated.

"It's stressful," Danny Price of Oklahoma told Tulsa's KJRH-TV of not being able to talk to his wife and other relatives on the vessel. "I'd like to hear from her and know that she's all right and being taken care of."

Travel agent Monte Akers of CruiseOne in Houston said he hasn't heard from a family of six he had booked on the sailing. But he said he was impressed with how Carnival was handling the situation so far.

Within hours of the fire, Carnival announced that passengers on the ship would get full refunds, and it later added a credit for a future cruise.

"Typically when these things happen, cruise lines will give vouchers for only a portion of the cruise," Akers said.

At the time of the fire, the Carnival Triumph was near the end of a four-night cruise to Mexico out of Galveston, Texas, which began on Thursday. Carnival said it is arranging to get passengers home from Mobile.

Contributing: Jayne Clark; the Associated Press

(c) Copyright 2013 USA TODAY, a division of Gannett Co. Inc.

Source: Copyright USA TODAY 2013

Story Tools Facebook Linkedin Twitter RSS Feed Email Alerts & Newsletters