News Column

Sharks Keep Cape Cod Rescuers on Alert

July 24, 2012

Doug Fraser

A decade ago if you told the average person you'd seen a great white shark from a Cape Cod beach, it was in the same league as saying you'd been abducted by aliens.

These sharks were elusive, feeding off dead whales far offshore.

But that's all changed in the past few years. It's almost as if great whites suddenly discovered there are pretty good live pickings just off Cape beaches. Recently, attacks on seals started happening in front of beachgoers in Chatham, Wellfleet and Truro.

While there hasn't been an attack on a human in Massachusetts since Joseph Troy Jr. went for a swim in Buzzards Bay in July 1936, was mauled and died on the operating table, lifeguards, beach administrators and emergency medical personnel have already turned the corner in accepting the fact that it may happen.

And they say they're ready if it ever occurs again.

Keith McFarland, the supervisor for lifeguards in the southern district of the Cape Cod National Seashore, said great whites were largely mythical when he started lifeguarding in 1994.

"We talked about them; we didn't see them," he said. "I don't know about beachgoers, but for some of the senior guards the shift started happening a couple of years ago. It was an abstract, and now it's a reality."

Procedures for National Seashore guards have changed in recent years. While they still train in the water and do fitness swims, they now swim alongshore in relatively shallow water and do not head straight out to a buoy farther offshore. Lifeguards at other town beaches said they do the same.

Lifeguards are also keeping swimmers closer to shore than they did before and have removed the seaward buoys at Nauset Light Beach.

As to how they would respond to an attack, most lifeguards say it's probably going to come down to decisions made on the beach.

"We're going out on rescue boards, not swimmers in the water," McFarland said. They will use multiple rescuers in the hope that would discourage the shark.

Are they still out there?

But, before they go out, they are supposed to determine whether the shark is still in the area. "We're not putting a responder at risk," he said.

It is a judgment call, said Chris Brewster, president of the United States Lifesaving Association, but the data supports going out right away.

"In very few cases of (great whites) attacking people do they continue to attack," he said.

Brewster believes the chance of an attack by a great white on a human is remote, that you have a much greater chance of an accident while driving to the beach. But Cape responders have still prepared for the worst-case scenario.

Greg Johnson, head lifeguard at Nauset Beach in Orleans, said there have been meetings with town safety officials talking about the protocol in the event of a shark attack.

"The first thing you do is decide if the scene is safe," Johnson said, comparing firefighters assessing whether a burning building is safe before they attempt a rescue. Johnson believes lifeguards may need more than just paddleboards, something more like a personal watercraft towing a sled, if they are going to go after a victim while the attack is under way.

"It's a reactionary process," Johnson said, "Things are developing. I don't think we're 100 percent, but we're talking about it."

Great white shark attacks remain a relatively rare event, with 139 worldwide from 1990 to 2011, 29 of them fatal. In the U.S. there have been just 106 in the past 85 years, with 13 fatalities. Seventy-eight of those attacks happened in California.

Alex Peabody, the retired director for aquatic safety for the California State Park system, agrees that rescue swimmers should not be in the water during an attack. His parks are equipped with personal watercraft and patrol boats, although those were purchased to save swimmers caught in rip currents, not for shark attacks, which remain relatively rare in the Golden State.

Surviving an attack

Fins in the water, whether harmless basking sharks, ocean sunfish or the real thing, have always prompted an evacuation from the water.

But now, behind the scenes, a shift has taken place, away from skepticism and toward preventing and preparing for the worst, the possibility of a shark attack on a human.

In 2004, the evidence that great whites were here was undeniable, as a 14-foot, 1,700-pound female great white became trapped for weeks in a lagoon on Naushon Island.

Around that time, McFarland said, pages were added to the lifeguard manual telling them how to respond to reports or sightings of sharks in the water and how to rescue a swimmer or surfer who has been bitten.

Most recently, McFarland was on Nauset Light Beach with other lifeguards when a shark either attacked or became entangled in a buoy that marked the seaward limit of the protected area. He said its whole body came up out of the water.

"That was really disconcerting to me," said McFarland, who believed it was a great white. Research has shown that great whites have various attack strategies, but quite often bite with the intent of inducing massive blood loss and death. They wait for the victim to die, then return to feed.

Improved medical care is largely responsible for bringing the fatality rate in great white attacks down from 60 percent in the early 1900s to around 20 percent today. The majority of sharks spotted by shark researcher Greg Skomal's team have been in the 14- to 16-foot range, with only one estimated at around 18 feet.

Studies support the theory that humans lack the fat content great whites prefer and that most attacks are exploratory.

International Shark Attack File data showed that more than 70 percent of great white attacks on humans were done by sharks greater than 10 feet in length, largely because at that size they have shifted from eating fish to marine mammals.

The survival rate was estimated at around 80 percent for sharks between 10 and 15 feet in length and 70 percent for those between 15 feet and 20 feet.

Beyond that, the number of attacks are rare and survival drops to around 10 percent.

'Right up against the clock'

For lifeguards, stopping the bleeding is the first priority after they have the victim on the beach. The call to town emergency personnel has already been made at the first sign of an attack, rescue and beach officials said. En route, emergency responders are already looking for information from those on the beach so that they can determine whether to call for a medical airlift, Eastham Fire Chief Glenn Olson said.

The goal is to get the trauma victim into surgery within what is called "The Golden Hour," beyond which statistics say complications and even death becomes more likely.

Cape & Islands EMS president William Flynn said lessons learned in warfare have transformed pre-hospital trauma care from treatment at the scene to the point where they are now trying to stabilize the patient but still get them on their way as quickly as possible.

"It's a challenge. You try to get the patient moving and stabilized. You put direct pressure on any site (where there is major blood loss) and start IV therapy. You're right up against the time clock right off the bat," Olson said.

All too familiar

Unfortunately, it's a routine that Outer Cape rescue personnel are all too familiar with in handling car accidents along Route 6.

Olson said their relationship with medical air flight companies as well as lifeguards, harbormasters, the Cape Cod National Seashore and other agencies like the Coast Guard is honed by other emergencies that happen every summer.

"The fact of the matter is trauma is all treated the same way, especially in pre-hospital care," Flynn said.

Town and Seashore park beaches have all-terrain vehicles that can get patients off the sand and into rescue vehicles relatively quickly. On the more remote off-road trails, such as the ones leading from Orleans to Chatham, there are beach patrol vehicles that can get rescuers to the scene.

Orleans Deputy Chief Tony Pike said his department has already had a lot of experience with marine rescues in remote areas, like clamming flats. A July 7 rescue in Pleasant Bay in which a young girl suffered severe lacerations from a boat propeller was pretty close to what could occur in a shark attack, Pike said.

In that case, Orleans rescue personnel had to travel to the patient by boat and, when medical helicopters couldn't fly, coordinated with the Coast Guard in Chatham to bring in an all-weather helicopter to fly the girl to Boston.

It was all done within 40 minutes of getting the rescue call from the harbormaster, Pike said. But those kinds of rescues require a lot of manpower, Pike said, and some feel the towns are other agencies are more in a reactive than a proactive role regarding shark attacks.

Some have not had meetings to specially work out protocols for such an emergency but are relying on how they handle their current cases.

"This could all be potentially new ground," Pike said, wondering whether the future will bring more seals, sharks and problems.

"Where are we going to be one more summer down the road?"

Source: (c)2012 the Cape Cod Times (Hyannis, Mass.) Distributed by MCT Information Services

Story Tools Facebook Linkedin Twitter RSS Feed Email Alerts & Newsletters