News Column

Bachmann Warning on Muslim Brotherhood Gets Stormy Reception

July 19, 2012
Michele Bachmann

Rep. Michele Bachmann is facing a public firestorm over her accusations that the Muslim Brotherhood is infiltrating the federal government and working for "America's demise."

Her attacks, including one directed at Huma Abedin, an aide to Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, prompted Sen. John McCain, the 2008 Republican nominee for president, to denounce her from the Senate floor on Wednesday, where he defended Abedin and called Bachmann's comments "specious and degrading."

The State Department also weighed in, saying Bachmann's remarks were "vicious and disgusting lies."

Bachmann's public campaign against radical Islamic influence in American life has been building for weeks, starting with a series of letters to oversight agencies at five separate federal departments. In them, she requested formal investigations into what she says are "influence operations" by the Brotherhood, an Islamic political organization.

The third-term Republican congresswoman, who has been challenged to produced specific evidence for her allegations, so far has gotten a cool response from agency heads. Meanwhile, she's being accused by some of launching a McCarthy-style witchhunt against Muslim-Americans.

Despite the backlash, Bachmann doubled down on her efforts Wednesday, alleging that the Obama administration "appeases our enemies instead of telling the truth about the threats our country faces."

Bachmann has long been a lightning rod of criticism from the left, but her public campaign against what she calls a "deep penetration" into government circles by Islamic radical groups is being met with denunciations from both sides of the political aisle.

Rep. Keith Ellison, a Minnesota Democrat and the first Muslim in Congress, went on CNN Tuesday night to fire back at Bachmann just as she was warning of the dangers of the Muslim Brotherhood and the Obama administration in a keynote speech at a Washington summit of Christians United for Israel, a staunchly pro-Israel evangelical group.

"This is McCarthyism at its worst," Ellison told the Star Tribune Wednesday, referring to the late Sen. Joe McCarthy, whose name became synonymous in the 1950s with his accusations of Communist infiltration in all walks of American life. "This is one of those moments when you can't stay silent," Ellison said.

Bachmann came to national prominence during the 2008 presidential campaign, when she questioned Obama's "anti-American" associations in a television interview with MSNBC host Chris Matthews. But this is the first time she has questioned the loyalty of a specific individual in Obama's administration, warning that Abedin has "routine access to the secretary and to policy-making."

McCain defended Abedin in personal terms, calling her a "hard-working and loyal servant of our country and our government.

"These attacks on Huma have no logic, no basis, and no merit," McCain said. "They need to stop now."

In a letter to Bachmann on Wednesday, Ellison demanded a "full accounting" of the sources of her allegations.

Bachmann's original letters, sent out June 13, all cite research by a group called the Center for Security Policy, founded by Frank Gaffney, a controversial figure who has feuded with figures of both the left and right, including conservative icon Grover Norquist, who accused him of bigotry.

Gaffney, who writes widely about the threat of Shariah, or Islamic law, in the United States, has said he was an informal foreign policy consultant in Bachmann's recent presidential bid.

Bachmann's letters were sent to the inspector general offices of the departments of state, justice, defense, homeland Security, and the Office of the Director of National Intelligence. The letters also were signed by Republican Reps. Louie Gohmert of Texas, Trent Franks of Arizona, Thomas Rooney of Florida and Lynn Westmoreland of Georgia.

Using nearly identical language, all the letters warn of government policies "that appear to be a result of influence operations conducted by individuals and organizations associated with the Muslim Brotherhood."

The letter to the State Department warns of Abedin's family connections to the Muslim Brotherhood, including "her late father, her mother and her brother."

Abedin, of mixed Indian and Pakistani heritage, is married to former New York congressman Anthony Weiner, who is Jewish.

In a written reply to Ellison on Friday, Bachmann said her inquiry "is not a question of singling out Ms. Abedin." But, she added, "I am particularly interested in exactly how ... she was able to avoid being disqualified for a security clearance."

In her letter to the State Department inspector general, Bachmann also questioned diplomatic initiatives "engaging" the newly elected Muslim Brotherhood leaders in Egypt and foreign aid grants to the Palestinian Authority, which she said benefits radical groups such as Hamas and Fatah.

A separate Bachmann letter criticizes Justice Department outreach efforts to Muslim groups in the U.S., as well as its "priority" on investigating bias crimes against "Muslims, Sikhs, and people of Arab and South Asian descent."

Bachmann's complaint against the Homeland Security Department faults officials there for equating jihadist threats with those posed by "Christian patriots," "Constitutionalists," and "militia extremists." At the Pentagon, she said, officials failed to "characterize accurately the jihadist motivations" of Maj. Nidal Hasan, the Fort Hood shooter.

Doug Welty, a spokesman for the State Department's Inspector General Office, said Bachmann's complaint appears focused on foreign policy differences with the Obama administration, rather than on the effectiveness of programs or misuse of government funds. "It's really outside of our mandate," he said.

The response has been equally cool from other investigative agencies. The inspector general office for the Department of Homeland Security, for example, told the Star Tribune it will not pursue Bachmann's allegations, citing "budgetary restraints."

Bachmann also took issue with National Intelligence Director James Clapper, who told Congress last year that the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt is "very heterogeneous (and) largely secular."

At Tuesday's Christians United summit, Bachmann laid out the biblical underpinnings of her views on the Middle East, recounting a "legend" about the angels asking if the blessings bestowed on the Israelites might be "too generous."

"Not really," God said, according to Bachmann's telling. "Just wait and see the neighbors I'm about to give them."

Source: (c)2012 Star Tribune (Minneapolis) Distributed by MCT Information Services

Story Tools Facebook Linkedin Twitter RSS Feed Email Alerts & Newsletters