News Column

Hispanic Republicans Assess Their Party's Failure in 2008

Nov. 19, 2008

Richard Kaplan--HispanicBusiness.com

GOP hispanics, republican vote, hispanic vote, hispanic influence, election 2008

Hispanic political leaders, some Republican and some not, spent the last two weeks assessing and arguing over the Republican Party's failure at the polls on November 4. A key lesson of the election, many declared, is that the Hispanic vote is increasing in strength and will be crucial for any party, be they Republican or Democrat, that desires to win the top national offices. For some Republican leaders, that is a cause for worry.

The Power Of The Hispanic Vote

In the 2008 national election, Hispanic votes climbed to 9 percent of the total votes cast, up from 8 percent in 2004, according to exit polls by Edison Media Research posted on CNN's Web site. That number remains below the actual share of the population that is Hispanic -- 15 percent -- but political analysts of all stripes recognize that the Hispanic vote is no longer a sleeping giant. That giant is awakening.

Despite the long-standing ties of Republican candidate John McCain to the Hispanic community of his home state of Arizona and his moderate approach to immigration reform, the Hispanic electorate heavily favored Sen. Barack Obama and his focus on "change." The Hispanic vote broke more than 2 to 1 in favor of Sen. Obama, with the president elect grabbing 67 percent to Sen. John McCain's 31 percent. Obama gained a sizable competitive advantage from the Hispanic vote.

Erica Bernal, director of political participation for NALEO, the National Associate of Latino Elected Officials, declared that the Latino vote had a significant impact in "reshaping the political map" by helping to decide the outcome of several key battleground states carried by President Bush in 2004. Bernal noted that "in Colorado, Florida New Mexico, Nevada and even Virginia the Latino vote helped Democrats put these states in the 'win' column." The Hispanic vote probably also flipped the state of Indiana from Republican red to Democratic blue, exit poll numbers suggest.

A Swing Vote?

Republican commentators are at pains to point out that the Hispanic vote this election was not a strictly partisan affair. It was driven by issues, the economy, and a dissatisfaction with the Republican brand. Neither party has a sure and steadfast grip on the loyalties of the Hispanic public.

For Frank Guerra, Hispanic media adviser for the McCain campaign, the Hispanic voter "is not an absolute party loyalist." The 2008 election offers strong evidence for Mr. Guerra's observation. Hispanics significantly shifted their preferences from the 2004 election. From 40-44 percent Hispanic support for the Republican candidate President George W. Bush in 2004, there was a 12 percent jump in favor of the Democrats this year.

"It's a very fluid population," Mr. Guerra said, "and it should be."

"Historically, upwards of 25 percent of Hispanics remain largely undecided going into an election day. And that's not because they are disinterested, it's because they are discerning. They are really trying to make the right decision. "

Mr. Guerra counts that as good news for Republicans. With the Hispanic voter not tied down by fixed party allegiances, the Republicans have a chance again in 2012 to recapture that vote.

But in addition, being a swing vote means the Hispanic community has increased leverage. Both sides have started campaigning and catering to the Hispanic population. In fact, said Mr. Guerra, "the Republicans going after the Hispanic vote did more to increase Hispanic power then almost anything else that has happened in the last 50 years."

Continued | 1 | 2 | Next >>

Comments

Total Comments: 3 | Pending Comments: 0

freespirit22
11/24/2008 3:57:46 PM PST
The Republican party blew it with the Hispanic vote. I am an independent that leans to right because of some of the values and ideals of the party. This time the Democrat party was better organized and they got the vote out. We need substance from the party not just words. They blew it big time with the immigration reform message from hardline republicans.


Carolina
11/21/2008 9:57:37 AM PST
In my opinion, the causitc rethoric ovr immigration turnedd a lot of people off. Many prominent republicans have suggested that is bad Spanish is being taught, in a global economy where the majority of our naighbor countried spea Spanish. They have suggested that the "Amarican Culture" is under threat because of the levels of immigration. They have insistently demonstrated ignorance over the immigration laws, furthering many myths over undocumented people. They will continue to lose until they get educated and change their views. John Mc Cain is a friend is a friend of the Hispanic community, but the party leaders and house memebers did him no favors. He lost because he is in the wrong party, not because of him.


Dr. V
11/21/2008 7:32:49 AM PST
The Republican brand has forever been tarnished by Pete Wilson and Prop 187. The recent immigration debate only served to revive the dying embers of that debacle. The conservative pundits on rant radio did a good job of letting Hispanics across the country know the GOP was not out to protect their interests. Given that conservative gas bags dominate 75% of talk radio, the DNC should send a thank you card to the Limbaughs, Hannitys, Coulters, and Ingrahams of the world for the fine job they did delivering the Hispanic vote to the Dem side. Keep up the good work!


Story Tools
SHARE THIS